It’s the billion-dollar question: how do you know if your private equity investment was actually worth it? You hear about friends who backed Uber in the early days, or a university endowment boasting double-digit returns, but what about your portfolio? When you can’t just check the ticker on CNBC, how do you really measure success?
Private equity is the secret sauce of portfolios for pension funds, sovereign wealth managers, and even high-net-worth individuals. But measuring its performance isn’t as straightforward as glancing at the S&P 500 or the NASDAQ. The numbers don’t scroll across the bottom of your TV screen, and the stories behind the returns are as varied as the investments themselves.
Here’s the catch: if you can’t accurately benchmark your private equity investments, how can you know if you’ve made the right calls or missed something big? Are you relying too much on glossy fund reports? How do you stack up against other investors who might have taken a different route?
In this article, you’ll learn why benchmarking private equity matters, how investors traditionally measure performance, the pitfalls in the current system, and some fresh ways to get a clearer read. Think of it as your map through the private markets maze.
You can’t just compare apples to oranges. Private equity is a whole fruit basket early-stage startups, leveraged buyouts, and everything in between. Data is patchy. Reporting is slow. And unlike your 401(k), there’s no daily price.
Imagine investing $1 million in a buyout fund. It could take years for the first results to trickle in, and even then, the numbers may be based on appraisals or estimates, not hard cash. You might see a glossy slide deck claiming “top-quartile” results, but what does that mean if every fund seems to claim the same?
It’s easy to be dazzled by stories like when Blackstone turned a $3 billion investment in Hilton into a $14 billion windfall after the financial crisis. But for every Hilton, there are duds that quietly fizzle out, and you rarely hear about those.
When you don’t have a solid benchmark, you risk more than just missing out on bragging rights. Investors can fall for confirmation bias, relying on selective success stories while ignoring quietly lagging deals. If you can’t see how your performance compares to other funds or public stocks, you might stick with a manager based on reputation instead of results.
For example, a pension fund might pour millions into a private equity manager who boasts about outpacing the S&P 500 by 3% per year. But without a clear, consistent benchmark, it’s hard to verify that claim. Did the manager beat the market after fees? Were the investments actually riskier, or just lucky? Fail to benchmark correctly, and you could be locking up your capital for a decade with little to show for it.
According to a 2024 CAIA report, many investors still use outdated or overly simplistic benchmarks, which can mask underperformance and skew risk assessments. The result? Billions in assets tied up in funds that may not deliver the real value you expect.
Here’s where you turn the corner. Instead of guesswork, you can use more sophisticated tools and comparisons to size up your private equity bets.
One solution is the Public Market Equivalent (PME) method. It lets you compare your private equity returns to a public benchmark index say, the S&P 500 by mimicking what your returns would have looked like if you’d invested your cash flows in the public market instead. According to Hamilton Lane, this approach gives you a clear answer: did your fund beat the market, or not?
But beware public market indices can’t capture private equity’s unique risks, illiquidity, and the timing of cash flows. PME tells a story, but not the whole novel.
Another approach is to use peer group comparisons. You match up your fund’s Internal Rate of Return (IRR) or Multiple on Invested Capital (MOIC) against similar funds raised in the same time period. This helps you see if your venture capital fund really is “top quartile” or just taking advantage of a good year.
If you have unique investment objectives, you might want to build a customized benchmark that reflects your specific needs. For example, a family office focused on social impact could create a benchmark combining financial and impact metrics, not just raw returns.
This is where platforms like Vyzer come into play. Vyzer empowers individuals and smaller institutions with private market visibility offering tools that help you consolidate, track, and benchmark alternative investments like private equity alongside your broader portfolio. It’s like having an endowment-style lens, without needing an endowment-sized team.
AI and machine learning are now moving into the benchmarking field, promising deeper insights from messy and incomplete data. Platforms are using advanced analytics to find patterns and flag risks early, helping you avoid costly mistakes.
Platforms like Vyzer that simplify data aggregation and visualization, this new era of benchmarking makes it easier for even individual investors to think and act like institutions.
When you benchmark better, you invest smarter. Data from S&P Global shows that private equity can outperform public markets by as much as 4% per year but only if you choose the right funds and strategies. By using PMEs, peer group comparisons, and AI-assisted tools, you can spot which managers are truly adding value and which are just riding the market’s coattails.
Take Yale University’s endowment, often cited as a gold standard in private equity investing. By focusing on rigorous benchmarking and consistently measuring performance against both public markets and peer funds, Yale has delivered annualized returns of over 11% for decades. Their approach? Relentless focus on data, manager selection, and accountability.
If you’re an individual investor or a small institution, you may not have Yale’s resources but you can still use these strategies on a smaller scale. Work with advisors who understand private markets. Demand transparency. Use every tool at your disposal.
So, the next time you review your private equity portfolio, don’t just rely on the glossy pitch books or word-of-mouth success stories. Insist on rigorous benchmarking whether it’s PME, peer comparisons, or a custom approach. Use the data, question the narrative, and push for accountability.
Are you asking the tough questions about your portfolio? What would your results look like if you measured them with the same rigor as the best in the business? And in a market where every advantage counts, can you afford not to benchmark smarter?
Q: What is benchmarking in private equity and why is it important?
A: Benchmarking in private equity means comparing the performance of private equity funds against relevant standards, such as public market indices or peer funds. This process is crucial for evaluating investment performance, managing risk, and holding fund managers accountable for results.
Q: What are the main techniques for benchmarking private equity investments?
A: The two primary approaches are public market comparisons and private market comparisons. Public market comparisons use indices from publicly traded markets as a reference, while private market comparisons evaluate performance relative to similar private equity funds, offering a more nuanced assessment.
Q: What challenges do investors face when benchmarking private equity?
A: Common challenges include a lack of standardized benchmarks, limited access to reliable data, and the inherent complexity of private equity investments, which span various strategies such as venture capital and leveraged buyouts.
Q: How can investors overcome the difficulties in benchmarking private equity?
A: Investors can leverage advanced analytics and artificial intelligence to improve data processing, develop customized benchmarks tailored to their specific goals, and collaborate with specialized experts or firms for deeper insights and more accurate assessments.
Q: Why might private equity outperform public markets, and how can benchmarking help maximize returns?
A: Private equity has the potential to outperform public markets by as much as 4% annually due to factors like active management and access to exclusive investment opportunities. Effective benchmarking helps investors identify top-performing funds, manage risks, and refine their strategies to enhance returns.
Vyzer is a modern alternative to the traditional family office, providing a single, secure hub for your financial life. More than just tracking, Vyzer delivers actionable forecasting and curated deal flow, empowering high-net-worth investors to confidently manage and grow their wealth. With instant visibility into your entire portfolio, you stay in control, making informed decisions on your terms instead of waiting on reports or advisors.
Read more
Looking for smart ways to grow passive income in the private markets? Our refreshed roundup spotlights five passive investing podcasts that consistently deliver high‑quality,...
Introduction Imagine managing your investments not by poring over spreadsheets or toggling between dashboards, but by simply guiding an intelligent digital agent that...
Imagine managing your entire financial life with the same ease as ordering takeout or hailing a ride. That’s the promise AI is bringing to wealth management. No more toggling...
The United States has entered a pivotal phase in nuclear energy development, making 2025 a critical year for nuclear energy investing. Driven by technological innovation, policy...
